Why Duplicate Content Hurts SEO and How to Fix It

Duplicate content can harm your SEO by confusing search engines and diluting rankings. Learn why it matters and how to avoid it.
Lawrence Hitches
December 8, 2024

Duplicate content is one of those pesky SEO issues that can quietly undermine your website's performance.

While it might seem harmless at first glance, search engines like Google see it as a barrier to providing the best results for users.

If your site serves up the same content across multiple pages or domains, you’re making it harder for search engines to rank your pages effectively and for users to trust your site.

In this guide, we’ll unpack what duplicate content is, why it’s a problem for SEO, and, most importantly, how to fix it.

What Is Duplicate Content?

Duplicate content refers to any instance where blocks of text are identical or nearly identical across different pages. This can happen within the same website (internal duplication) or between multiple sites (external duplication).

While not always intentional, it’s more common than you might think.

Research by Raven Tools estimates that nearly 29% of web pages contain duplicate content.

Examples of Duplicate Content

  • E-commerce product descriptions: Copying text directly from a manufacturer’s catalog without modification.
  • Syndicated blog posts: Republishing articles across multiple domains with no added value.
  • Session ID URLs: Creating unique URLs for the same page based on user session data.
  • Printer-friendly versions of pages: Offering a second version of the same content in a format optimized for printing.

Even subtle variations in URLs, like switching between https:// and http://, or using "www" and non-"www" prefixes, can create duplication issues.

Google Treats Duplicate Content Like Repeated TV Channels

Imagine you’re flipping through TV channels and come across the same show airing on multiple stations. Would you keep flipping through the duplicates, or just stick to the first one?

Google thinks the same way.

When it finds duplicate content, it picks the most relevant version and skips over the rest.

This helps explain why duplicate content doesn’t contribute to better search results.

Instead, it creates unnecessary repetition, which Google avoids to ensure users find diverse and valuable content.

Why Duplicate Content Hurts SEO

When search engines encounter duplicate content, their algorithms must decide which version of the content to index and rank. This process isn’t perfect, and it can lead to serious SEO drawbacks for your site.

1. Keyword Dilution

Duplicate content spreads keyword relevance across multiple pages instead of consolidating it into one authoritative page.

For instance, if two pages contain the same keywords and information, search engines may rank neither of them highly, as the value is split.

2. Loss of Backlink Equity

Backlinks are a crucial SEO factor. When other websites link to different versions of the same content, the link equity (ranking power passed by links) is split between those duplicates.

Instead of boosting one page’s authority, the impact of backlinks is watered down.

3. Indexing Problems

Search engines aim to index unique, valuable content.

When faced with duplicates, they may skip indexing certain pages altogether, limiting the visibility of your site.

This can hurt your crawl budget, the number of pages search engines crawl on your site within a given timeframe.

4. User Frustration

It’s not just about search engines. Users encountering repetitive content may find your site unhelpful or untrustworthy, leading to higher bounce rates and fewer conversions.

5. E-Commerce Sites Face Unique Challenges

For e-commerce websites, duplicate content is a common and costly problem.

Whether it’s reusing manufacturer-provided product descriptions or creating multiple variations of a page for different sizes or colours, these practices often lead to duplication issues.

Search engines struggle to decide which version to rank, meaning your site could lose visibility and potential traffic.

This highlights the need for e-commerce site owners to prioritise unique descriptions and optimise their content strategy to avoid cannibalising their own rankings.

Why Search Engines Prioritise Unique Content

At its heart, Google’s goal is to provide value.

Duplicate content doesn’t align with this mission because it doesn’t enhance the user experience.

Instead of offering something new or useful, duplicates repeat what’s already available, making them less appealing for search engines to rank.

This value-driven perspective emphasises why original, high-quality content isn’t just an SEO best practice, it’s a necessity for standing out in search results and building trust with your audience.

Benefits of Unique Content:

  • Better Rankings: Original content avoids the dilution issues caused by duplicates, giving you a better chance of ranking on page one.
  • Increased Backlinks: Unique, helpful content is more likely to be shared and linked by other websites, boosting your site’s domain authority.
  • Improved User Engagement: Users are more likely to stay on your site, explore other pages, and return if they find fresh and relevant information.

Think of it this way: search engines are like librarians recommending books. They’re more likely to suggest a well-written, original work than a reprinted copy with nothing new to offer.

Common Causes of Duplicate Content

Duplicate content doesn’t always happen on purpose. Often, it’s the result of technical SEO issues or outdated practices. Here are some of the most common culprits:

1. Dynamic URLs

Many content management systems (CMS) create unique URLs for the same content based on user preferences, session IDs, or tracking parameters. For example:

  • example.com/product?id=123
  • example.com/product/123?session=abc123

2. HTTP and HTTPS Confusion

If both the secure (HTTPS) and non-secure (HTTP) versions of your site are live, search engines may index both, creating duplicate pages.

3. Canonicalisation Errors

When canonical tags (used to indicate the preferred version of a page) are missing or incorrectly implemented, search engines may treat similar pages as duplicates.

4. Scraped or Syndicated Content

If other websites copy your content without permission, or if you syndicate your own content to other platforms, it can result in duplicate content issues.

How to Fix Duplicate Content

The good news?

Fixing duplicate content is manageable, and the rewards are worth it.

By addressing the issue, you’ll improve your SEO performance and ensure your content reaches the right audience.

1. Canonical Tags

Add canonical tags to your HTML to tell search engines which version of a page is the original. This is especially useful when you have multiple URLs pointing to the same content.

For example:

<link rel="canonical" href="https://example.com/original-page">

2. 301 Redirects

Use 301 redirects to permanently send visitors and search engines to the preferred URL. This not only fixes duplicate content but also consolidates backlink equity.

3. Consistent URL Structures

Avoid variations in URLs by standardizing your site’s structure. Tools like Google Search Console can help identify problematic URLs.

4. Set Pages to ‘Noindex’

For duplicate pages that serve a purpose (e.g., printer-friendly versions), use a noindex tag to prevent them from appearing in search results.

5. Audit Regularly

Run regular content audits with tools like Copyscape, SEMrush, or Screaming Frog to identify duplicate content and fix it before it becomes a problem.

Real-World Example: E-Commerce Websites

Imagine an online store selling electronics.

They copy product descriptions directly from manufacturers, resulting in hundreds of pages with identical content.

Search engines struggle to determine which page to rank, and the site loses out to competitors with unique descriptions.

To fix this, the store could:

  1. Rewrite product descriptions to include original details or user reviews.
  2. Add canonical tags to product variations (e.g., color or size options).
  3. Redirect outdated URLs to the most relevant pages.

Key Takeaways

By focusing on originality and addressing technical causes, you’ll create a website that search engines love and users trust:

  • Duplicate content creates confusion for search engines and users, reducing your site’s SEO performance.
  • Unique, high-quality content builds authority, improves rankings, and enhances user engagement.
  • Simple fixes like canonical tags, 301 redirects, and regular audits can resolve most duplicate content issues.

FAQs

What Is the Most Common Cause of Duplicate Content?

Dynamic URLs are a frequent culprit. They create unique links for the same content based on session IDs or tracking data, confusing search engines.

Does Duplicate Content Lead to a Google Penalty?

Not necessarily. Google doesn’t typically penalise sites for unintentional duplicate content but may ignore duplicates, reducing their visibility. Intentional plagiarism or deceptive practices, however, can result in penalties.

How Can I Prevent Duplicate Content in the Future?

Adopt good practices like using canonical tags, creating original content, and regularly auditing your site for duplication issues. Standardise URL structures and avoid publishing the same material across multiple domains.

Our SEO Services.

screen_search_desktop
Technical SEO

Great SEO starts with solid foundations. Our in-depth website audit will help us uncover any “behind the scenes” technical issues that are hindering your SEO.


Learn more

shopping_basket
eCommerce SEO

In the world of eCommerce, competition is fierce. Our eCommerce SEO specialists have mastered what works and will help you reach more shoppers with credit cards in hand.

 

Learn more

location_on
Local SEO

With 4 out of 5 customers turning to search to find local information, our local SEO services will help your business show up at the right place, right time.

 

Learn more

domain
Enterprise SEO

Great SEO starts with solid foundations. Our in-depth website audit will help us uncover any “behind the scenes” technical issues that are hindering your SEO.

 

Learn more

link
Link Building

Our link-building campaigns use ethical, 100% white-hat techniques to build high quality backlinks to your store. This shows Google you’re a trusted authority and worth putting higher in the search results!

 

Learn more

phonelink_ring
Digital PR

StudioHawk can help to minimise the loss of traffic to your new domain or CMS. We map and implement redirects, provide recommendations, help with site structure, monitor traffic, and report to you on the progress and any impact on your organic traffic.

 

Learn more

storefront
Small Business SEO

Forget generic SEO services. Every small business is different, and things change quickly. Our specialist small business SEO experts will tailor a unique SEO strategy that works best for your business, budget and niche.

 

Learn more

language
International SEO

We’ll find your audience whenever they are in the world. We’ll craft masterful campaigns that cater to their linguistic and cultural nuances and help grow your brand globally.

 

Learn more

Subscribe and keep up on all things SEO.